A Minnesota homeowner’s guide to choosing the right type of metal roof
If you’re researching the type of metal roof that’s best for your home, you’re already thinking long-term — and that’s exactly how Minnesota homeowners should approach roofing decisions. But the “best” depends on what you’re looking for.
Between heavy snowfall, hailstorms, and at times severe weather conditions, roofs in Minnesota take a beating. That’s why more homeowners are turning to metal roofing. Metal roofs last longer, handle extreme weather better, and require far less maintenance than traditional asphalt shingles.
But here’s the catch: not all metal roofs are the same. Some prioritize sleek, modern design. Others focus on rustic aesthetics. Some offer maximum durability, while others are more budget-friendly. Choosing the wrong type of metal roof can mean paying for features you don’t need — or missing out on the protection you actually do.
This guide breaks down the most common types of metal roofing, explains the pros and cons of each, and helps you determine which option best fits your home, budget, and preferences.
Looking For Something In Particular?
- Why Choosing the Right Type of Metal Roof Matters in Minnesota
- Standing Seam Metal Roofing
- Stone Coated Metal Roofing
- Log Home Metal Roofing
- Ag Barn Metal Roofing
- Arrowline Metal Roofing
- Comparing the Best Type of Metal Roof for Minnesota Homes
- How New Century Exteriors Helps You Choose the Right Type of Metal Roof
- Install the Right Type of Metal Roof for Your Home
Why Choosing the Right Type of Metal Roof Matters in Minnesota
Metal roofing works exceptionally well in Minnesota — but deciding on the specific type of metal roof depends on your home style and preferences.
Key factors Minnesota homeowners must consider include:
- Snow shedding and ice buildup
- Wind resistance
- Hail impact protection
- Long-term performance in freeze-thaw conditions
- Visual fit with the home’s architecture
Below, we’ll compare the most popular types of metal roofs New Century Exteriors installs so you can make a confident, informed decision.
Standing Seam Metal Roofing (The Ole Reliable)
Overview
Standing seam metal roofing is one of the most durable and modern metal roofing systems available. It consists of long vertical metal panels with raised seams that lock together above the roof surface.
Durability
Standing seam roofs typically last 50–70+ years. Because the fasteners are concealed, there are fewer opportunities for leaks, making this system extremely reliable during Minnesota’s freeze-thaw cycles, heavy snowfall, and high winds.
Noise
With proper underlayment and decking, standing seam roofs are no louder than asphalt shingles. Rain and hail noise is minimal when installed correctly.
Price
Standing seam is one of the higher-priced metal roof options at $13 – $18 per sq ft installed. This is due to premium materials and labor-intensive installation. However, its lifespan and minimal maintenance often make it the most cost-effective choice long term.
Aesthetic
Clean, sleek, and architectural. Standing seam metal roofs pair well with modern homes, custom builds, and upscale renovations.
Best For
Homeowners who want maximum longevity, minimal maintenance, and a modern appearance that will last for over half a century.
Type of Metal Roof: Stone Coated Metal Roofing
Overview
Stone coated is a hybrid-like type of metal roofing that consists of steel panels coated with stone granules, designed to replicate the appearance of tile, shake, or dimensional shingles.
Durability
Stone coated metal roofs typically last 40–60 years and offer excellent hail resistance — a major benefit in Minnesota’s storm-prone regions.
Noise
One of the quietest metal roofing options due to the stone coating and layered installation system.
Price
Mid-range to upper-mid pricing at $10 – $15 per sq ft installed. More expensive than basic metal shingles but generally less than standing seam.
Aesthetic
Textured and dimensional, offering a high-end look that complements both traditional and luxury homes. We offer this type of metal roof in shake, shingle, and tile.
Best For
Homeowners who want premium durability with a textured, upscale appearance that blends well with classic home styles.
Log Home Metal Roofing (Hand-Split Wood Shake Look)
Overview
This type of metal roof replicates the rustic beauty of hand-split cedar shake, but is made entirely from metal.
Durability
These roofs last 50+ years and eliminate common wood shake issues like rot, splitting, insect damage, and moisture absorption. They perform exceptionally well under snow loads and ice.
Noise
Comparable to other metal shingle systems and very quiet with proper underlayment.
Price
Premium pricing at $11 – $17 per sq ft installed due to specialized design and craftsmanship.
Aesthetic
Rustic and natural. Perfect for log homes, cabins, lake homes, and rural Minnesota properties.
Best For:
Log Home homeowners who love the wood shake look but want a roof that actually survives Minnesota’s harsh winters without constant maintenance.
Ag Barn Metal Roofing (Exposed Fastener Panels)
Overview
Ag-style (short for agricultural-style) metal roofing uses ribbed metal panels secured with exposed fasteners. While common on barns and agricultural buildings, some homeowners consider it for residential use.
Durability
Typically lasts 30–40 years. While strong against snow and wind, exposed fasteners may require maintenance over time, especially with Minnesota’s freeze-thaw cycles.
Noise
Can be louder than other metal roof systems if installed without adequate insulation.
Price
At $6 – $9 per sq ft installed, this is the most affordable type of metal roofing in terms of upfront cost.
Aesthetic
Industrial or agricultural in appearance, which may not suit residential neighborhoods.
Best For
Barns, garages, outbuildings, or homeowners prioritizing budget over aesthetics and durability.
Arrowline Metal Roofing (Metal Shingles)
Overview
Arrowline metal roofing uses interlocking metal shingles designed to mimic the look of traditional asphalt shingles — but with the durability of metal. At first glance, it looks like regular roofing.
Durability
Arrowline systems typically last 40–70 years. The interlocking design provides excellent wind resistance and performs well under snow and ice loads common in Minnesota.
Noise
Very quiet when installed with proper underlayment, comparable to standard shingle roofs.
Price
Mid-to-high price range at $9 – $14 per sq ft installed. More expensive than asphalt shingles but generally less than standing seam systems.
Aesthetic
Traditional and clean. This is a great option for homeowners who want the benefits of metal roofing without a modern or industrial appearance. They look just like regular shingles.
Best For
Homes in traditional neighborhoods where homeowners want metal durability without changing the actual look of their roof.
Comparing Types of Metal Roof for Minnesota Homes
Choosing the best type of metal roof depends on what you value most.
For those wanting:
- Maximum durability: Standing seam
- Traditional roof appearance: Arrowline metal shingles
- Luxury texture: Stone coated metal
- Rustic cabin look: Log home metal roofing
- Budget-friendly metal: Ag barn panels
No single metal roof is “best” for everyone — but there is a best option for your home, location, and goals.
How New Century Exteriors Helps You Choose the Right Type of Metal Roof
At New Century Exteriors, we don’t believe in one-size-fits-all roofing. We help you choose the right type of metal roof based on:
- Your home’s architecture
- Local weather exposure
- Budget and long-term goals
- Aesthetic preferences (want something modern-looking or traditional?)
- Desired lifespan and maintenance level (are you moving soon or settling down?)
Our team specializes in metal roofing installations designed specifically for Minnesota’s climate, ensuring your roof performs beautifully for decades.
Install the Right Type of Metal Roof for Your Home
Now you know the differences between the different types of metal roofing. The best part is, you’re just one call away from treating your home with the right metal roofing, installed by the best metal roofers in Minneapolis!
Whether you’re drawn to standing seam, metal shingles, or a rustic shake-style system, we’ll walk you through your options and install a roof built to last. Let’s give your home the protection and look it deserves.
When you’re ready for a new roof…
Contact New Century Exteriors today to schedule your free metal roofing consultation and discover which type of metal roof is best for your Minnesota home.